Is the Plus Size Industry Really Moving Forward?
Those of us older plus-size women can remember a time when “mail order” sack-like house dresses, Lane Bryant, and the men’s department were the main shopping options for our size. We were told to dress all in black or navy because dark, solid colors were considered more slimming; god forbid anyone see our bodies for what they actually were – FAT. Even now there are designers who will not size their clothing lines for larger women because they don’t want their designs “ruined” by being on a lumpy “imperfect” body.
And yet some progress has been made in the plus-size industry in just the past few years. The classics like Lane Bryant and Avenue are still around. There are popular mainstream brands that have added plus sizing to their product lines – Anthropologie, Loft, Madewell, Target, Nordstrom. However, some brands are declaring themselves as “catering to ALL sizes of women” to get in on the burgeoning plus-size market, but still stopping their sizing at a relatively low level. They are actually catering to the “small fats,” and not including the larger sized woman. It’s frustrating (if not downright disheartening), as a larger plus sized woman, to not be included in “all.” Isn’t “all” ALL??
Why do some of us have to keep fighting to be included? In Getting DRESSED??? In Feeling Seen?? In Not Feeling Like a Second Class Citizen?
I so appreciate the stores that are including plus size…and doing it RIGHT. The first time I walked into Anthropologie, I was Blown Away by the size and appealing merchandising of the plus-size section. It was right smack in front of the register counter and ran the full-length of the store. It had its own clearance section…which was huge!! So often in “mixed size” stores the entire plus section is next to, if not mixed in with, all the other departments’ clearance section. It’s in the back of the store or the basement, in some dreary section of the store off the main drag.
It’s no wonder so many women have been shopping mainly online for their plus size clothing. The problem with that is brick&mortar stores are losing revenue to online retailers and then they don’t want to give plus size clothing much real estate because there’s not as much return as straight sizes. It’s a catch-22. We don’t want to shop in the messy basement…but because we don’t spend our money there, they’re going to keep us in the messy basement! I think we need to keep trying to vote with our $$ and show the retailers If They Sell It, We Will Come.
Another area that is slow-growing is visual representation in marketing. It’s just not enough for brands to CARRY plus size. They need to SHOW the items in their marketing on plus-size bodies! It’s like they’re saying, we’re going to carry big clothes for you, but shhh, we don’t want it to LOOK like we are. We’ll take your money, but let’s just keep that between us, shall we? Ugh. And not just PRETTY plus size models! I want to see how something looks on a big belly! I want to be able to look at a picture and know that if an item looks good on the model it will look good on me! I can’t tell that At All from a 5’9″, long-legged, flat-stomached model.
I hate to whine about something (do I though??) that is, truly, so much better than it used to be. BUT, just because it’s “better,” relatively speaking, still doesn’t make it GOOD. And The Plus Size Industry Should Be As Good as The Straight Size! And I’m afraid that if the industry seems better that companies will stop trying. They’ll think the problem is solved. But it’s not.
So with all the progress that has been made, there is the need for So Much More. I think until EVERY clothing store carries plus sizes…and fashion marketing campaigns show large plus size women…and until every single item in straight sizes has a plus-size counterpart…the fight is not over. Is the plus-size industry moving forward? Yes. But it’s just coming around the first bend. There’s still a long way to go.
And what can you do to help?
- Spend your money at size-inclusive brands.
- When you can, go in-store to shop.
- Use your social media voice to tag brands in requests for more sizing range.
What I Wore for My Rant
- NYDJ floral top, size 3x. In straight size here and plus size here.
- White Gloria Vanderbilt Amanda tapered jeans, size 22W short
This post contains affiliate links, which means that I may receive a small commission if you buy something as a result of clicking that link, at no extra cost to you. I appreciate you shopping through my links.
jodie filogomo
That’s how it should be for every size definitely. I know it’s hard to try to carry everything, but that’s what we need.
ALONG with marketing for all ages too.
I think progress takes time. I mean, heck, look at women’s right. It’s still a thing and we got the right to vote how long ago??
Happy, happy weekend, Bettye
XOOX
Jodie
Pauline starsmore
What a lovely top, the pattern sort of reminds me of a skirt or dress I had as a child, so cool looking.
Tammy
Bettye, I so agree with you!! It’s frustrating to see lovely clothes and then find out that they only fit straight sizes. Or to find plus sized clothing that’s modeled on thin women. Because, I’m sorry, but a size 12 is not the average in plus sizes! That’s why blogs such as yours are so important. I get to see clothing on someone’s REAL body… someone who has a body similar to my own. Thanks for being there! 🙂
bettyewp
“It’s frustrating to see lovely clothes and then find out that they only fit straight sizes” YES! SO frustrating! I want all the options that other women do! Why WOULDN’T I??
Maria
You are beautiful
bettyewp
You’re making me blush.
Tina von Tinaspinkfriday
Oh yes Bettye. We need all clothes in all sizes!
XO Tina
bettyewp
Here’s to All The Sizes!
Judi
Amen, Bettye! You must be in my mind because I think the same thing from time to time. It is also difficult to find really well-crafted clothing made from high quality fabrics. I can’t afford $400-500 for a single, basic blazer or skirt.
I’m also with you on showing garments on body types you are marketing them to. By now I have trained myself to imagine (based on measurements given in the description) what a piece may look like on me, but wouldn’t it be nice to see it.
And like you, I only wear flat shoes. I see so many beautiful dresses, but all of the models are wearing 3+ inch heels, and that, too, affects the final look of an outfit.
Kudos to Avenue which carries a true range of sizes, and offers relatively inexpensive “basics” (and amazing clearance deals), up to more expensive pieces and trendy, seasonal items. I also like Old Navy for great sales and a range that for gals of our age, still has many items that will flatter our figures and satisfy our preferences (for styles that are meant for a decades younger woman.)
In spite of any gaps or shortcomings, things have come a very, very long way.
bettyewp
I’ve been reading that Avenue is not in good shape, financially. They’ve closed a few stores already this month…but it may be bigger than that https://www.chainstoreage.com/finance-0/new-york-post-avenue-may-shutter-all-stores/
Yes, we’ve come a long way (baby!) but there should be no resting on laurels! There’s more to do. I think social media has been a HUGE element of the changes, because it gives so many more people a voice and let’s them discover that they are not alone in their missions of change and through social platforms they can band together in their purpose. Huzzah!
Iris
I’m not a plus size, but I totally agree with you. It’s kinda like “old lady” clothes. Either they don’t carry anything I’d wear and cater to just kids, or if they do have anything there’s not much. I definitely feel your pain.
But, I love the outfit you’re wearing. Very becoming on you.
Grace & Peace,Iris
http://www.IrisOriginalsRamblings.com